A smooth sauce that coats the pasta
Before you start
Whisk the milk into the butter-and-flour mixture gradually. Let each addition become smooth before adding more. Reduce the heat before stirring in cheese so the sauce is less likely to turn grainy.
What to look for
Leave the macaroni slightly firm before baking because it continues cooking in the sauce. The sauce should look a little looser before baking than you want it on the plate. Check the center is hot; a baked casserole should reach 165°F / 74°C.
Make the next batch easier
Use a shallow baking dish to distribute the topping evenly. When scaling up, a second dish can preserve the original depth better than one deep container.
FoodSafety.gov: safe minimum cooking temperatures