Compare housing choices over the years you expect to stay
A mortgage payment and rent are not directly comparable costs. A mortgage includes principal that can build equity, while ownership also brings transaction costs, maintenance and other expenses. Renting keeps the down payment available for other uses, but rent can rise. This calculator puts a simplified version of those cash flows over one chosen holding period so you can see which assumptions drive the result.
Use it to investigate a decision, not to declare that buying or renting is always superior. Location, property condition, flexibility and the actual financing offer matter. The result is most useful when you can defend the price, rent, ownership-cost rate and time horizon you enter.
What the calculation includes
The model assumes a thirty-year fixed-rate mortgage. Down payment equals price multiplied by the down-payment percentage; the remainder is financed. Monthly principal and interest use the standard amortization formula. Ownership cash paid starts with the down payment plus 3% of price for buying costs, then adds mortgage payments and annual ownership costs spread monthly.
The ownership-cost percentage is applied to modeled home value. Value changes once each year at your appreciation assumption, so the following year's cost allowance changes too. Rent rises annually at the selected rent-growth rate. At the end of the stay, the model calculates equity as home value minus remaining debt and assumes 6% of final value for selling costs.
Net modeled buying cost is cash paid − ending equity + selling costs. Net renting cost is accumulated rent. The 3% and 6% transaction assumptions are fixed within this tool; they are not quotes or legally required charges. The model does not invest the renter's retained down payment, include income-tax effects or model the exact timing of every cash flow.
Enter a fair comparison
- Compare properties that meet similar needs. A larger purchased home and a smaller rental answer a lifestyle question as well as a financial one.
- Enter a plausible purchase price, down payment and actual quoted rate.
- Set ownership costs using taxes, insurance, maintenance and association expenses where relevant. Avoid counting mortgage principal and interest again inside that percentage.
- Enter comparable rent and a clear annual increase assumption.
- Test several stay lengths and appreciation rates. Treat a result that reverses with a small change as sensitive, not certain.
Three scenarios worth running
A short stay with substantial transaction costs
For a $400,000 home and 20% down, the opening down payment is $80,000 and the model's buying-cost allowance is $12,000. At a constant $400,000 sale value, its selling-cost allowance is $24,000. Those transaction assumptions total $36,000 before financing and operating expenses. A two-year stay gives much less time to spread those costs than a ten-year stay, which is why the holding period deserves its own comparison.
Testing appreciation rather than assuming it
Run the same home with 0% appreciation, then with 3%. After one year, modeled value is $400,000 in the first case and $412,000 in the second. That $12,000 difference affects equity, but higher value also increases the modeled selling charge and later ownership-cost allowance. Appreciation is an input, not cash already earned, and a sale price can be lower than the purchase price.
Rent growth changes a long comparison
At $2,000 monthly rent, the first year costs $24,000. With a 3% annual increase, year-two rent becomes $2,060 monthly, or $24,720 for that year. The two-year rent total is $48,720. Repeat with zero growth to isolate the effect. Then consider lease terms and local evidence rather than treating a single annual percentage as a guarantee.
Read the headline with its missing costs in view
The output labels the cheaper option within this model. It is not a complete investment comparison because retained cash is not assigned a return on the renting side. It also does not include every moving expense, utility difference, mortgage-insurance charge or major repair. A roof replacement is not necessarily captured well by a smooth annual allowance.
Use the rent-versus-buy guide to build a common-date comparison and the mortgage affordability calculator to check whether the monthly housing commitment fits. Restrict this thirty-year mortgage model to stays of thirty years or less; it is not designed to continue a paid-off loan indefinitely.
Frequently asked questions
Does the tool treat mortgage principal as a permanent expense?
Payments are included in cash paid, but ending equity is subtracted. This recognizes the principal remaining in the property under the assumed sale scenario.
Are the buying and selling percentages adjustable?
Not in the current form. It uses 3% at purchase and 6% at sale. If your actual costs differ materially, calculate that difference separately.
Is the renter's down payment invested?
No. The model omits returns on retained cash and monthly cost differences. That omission can materially affect a long-term comparison.
What belongs in the ownership-cost percentage?
Include a scenario allowance for taxes, insurance, maintenance and association costs as applicable. Do not include mortgage principal and interest a second time.
Does appreciation happen monthly?
No. The model updates home value once per year. This is a simplified annual path, not a forecast of market prices throughout the year.
Can net buying cost be negative?
Yes, if modeled ending equity exceeds cash paid plus selling costs. That reflects the assumptions, especially appreciation, and is not guaranteed profit.
Are mortgage tax deductions included?
No. Tax effects depend on individual circumstances and applicable rules. Keep them separate rather than assuming every owner receives the same benefit.
What if I do not know how long I will stay?
Run a short, middle and longer scenario. If buying works only at the longest stay, recognize that your uncertainty is financially important.
Methodology & sources
This is an undiscounted housing cash-flow model with annual price and rent changes, monthly loan amortization, and fixed transaction-cost assumptions. Consult CFPB home-buying resources for financing context and our methodology for limitations. Examples and implementation alignment reviewed November 13, 2026.